• Latest
  • Trending
[New York Times]Indian Court Hands Down Symbolic Sentence for Outspoken Lawyer

[New York Times]Indian Court Hands Down Symbolic Sentence for Outspoken Lawyer

2 years ago
[Daily Excelsior]Whether you followed lockdown rules may have been influenced by your genetics – new research – Jammu Kashmir Latest News | Tourism | Breaking News J&K

[Daily Excelsior]Whether you followed lockdown rules may have been influenced by your genetics – new research – Jammu Kashmir Latest News | Tourism | Breaking News J&K

1 hour ago
[The Northlines]Do justice to protesting Rehbars – Northlines

[The Northlines]Do justice to protesting Rehbars – Northlines

2 hours ago
[Hindustan Times]Climate crisis link to March-April heatwave

[Hindustan Times]Climate crisis link to March-April heatwave

2 hours ago
[DW.com]Climate change made deadly South Asian heat wave ’30 times more likely’ | DW | 23.05.2022

[DW.com]Climate change made deadly South Asian heat wave ’30 times more likely’ | DW | 23.05.2022

2 hours ago
[Business Standard]Pak govt says polls to be held next year, rejects ousted PM Khan’s demand

[Business Standard]Pak govt says polls to be held next year, rejects ousted PM Khan’s demand

3 hours ago
[The Hindu]Chief Ministers competing to harass Muslims, says Mehbooba

[The Hindu]Chief Ministers competing to harass Muslims, says Mehbooba

4 hours ago
[Free Press Journal]Several shows of Kangana Ranaut’s ‘Dhaakad’ cancelled due to no audience, replaced with ‘Bhool Bhulaiyaa 2’

[Free Press Journal]Several shows of Kangana Ranaut’s ‘Dhaakad’ cancelled due to no audience, replaced with ‘Bhool Bhulaiyaa 2’

4 hours ago
[Daily Excelsior]Declared Dead, Newborn Found Alive At Graveyard In J&K’s Banihal – Jammu Kashmir Latest News | Tourism | Breaking News J&K

[Daily Excelsior]Declared Dead, Newborn Found Alive At Graveyard In J&K’s Banihal – Jammu Kashmir Latest News | Tourism | Breaking News J&K

4 hours ago
[Telangana Today]Asia Cup 2022: Pakistan hold India to 1-1 draw in opening Pool A match

[Telangana Today]Asia Cup 2022: Pakistan hold India to 1-1 draw in opening Pool A match

6 hours ago
[Hurriyet ] Another nuclear threat from Russia!  They shared the images and showed their strength…

[Hurriyet ] Another nuclear threat from Russia! They shared the images and showed their strength…

7 hours ago
[Oneindia]Family pension rules relaxed for missing Central government employees

[Oneindia]Family pension rules relaxed for missing Central government employees

7 hours ago
[Scroll.in]Hockey, Asia Cup, India vs Pakistan live updates: India 1-0 up after Q3 through Selvam Karthi

[Scroll.in]Hockey, Asia Cup, India vs Pakistan live updates: India 1-0 up after Q3 through Selvam Karthi

7 hours ago
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
Tuesday, May 24, 2022
  • Login
Pakistan News Updates
  • Home
  • USA News
    • Bloomberg
    • Chicago Tribune News
    • CNN News
    • Fox News
    • Huffington Post News
    • Los Angeles Times News
    • ESPN
    • NBC News
    • New York Time News
    • Newsweek News
    • Reddit News
    • Reuters News
    • Time News
    • USA TODAY News
    • Washington Post News
    • Wall Street Journal
  • UK News
    • BBC News
    • Cambridge News UK News
    • Daily Express UK News
    • Daily Mail Online News
    • The Guardian News
    • The Huffington Post UK News
    • The Independent News
    • The Irish Times UK News
    • The Telegraph News
  • Chinese News
    • Beijing Bulletin News
    • China Digital Times News
    • China Military News
    • Chinadaily.com.cn News
    • Ecns News
    • People’s Daily Online News
    • Shanghai Daily News
    • South China Morning Post News
    • SupChina News
    • The China Post News
    • Xinhuanet News
    • Xinwengao News
  • Indian News
    • Business Standard News
    • Daily Excelsior News
    • Deccan Chronicle News
    • Free Press Journal News
    • Hindustantimes News
    • India Today News
    • Kashmir Reader News
    • NDTV News
    • News18 News
    • Northlines News
    • Oneindia News
    • Patrika News
    • Rising Kashmir News
    • Scroll.in News
    • State Times News
    • Telangana Today News
    • The Asian Age News
    • The Financial Express News
    • The Hindu News
    • The Indian Express News
    • The Quint News
    • Times of India News
    • ZeeNews 24 News
  • Arab News
    • Saudigazette
    • Albawaba News
    • Aljazera News
    • Arab News
    • UAE News Media
      • Al Arabiya News
      • Al bayan News
      • Al Ittihad Newspaper News
      • UAE today News
      • The National.ae News
      • Khaleej Times News
      • Emirates 24/7 News
  • Other Media
    • European News Media
      • French News Media
        • France 24 News
        • France Diplomatie News
        • Le Monde diplomatique News
        • RFI News
        • The Local News
        • The Paris News
      • German News Media
        • DEUTSCHLAND.de News
        • SPIEGEL ONLINE News
        • ZEIT News
    • Russian News Media
      • RT News
      • Russia Insider News
      • Sputnik News
      • TASS News
      • The Moscow Times News
    • Canadian News Media
      • CBC News
      • CityNews Toronto News
      • CTV News
      • Financial Post News
      • Global News
      • Reuters News
      • The Globe and Mail News
      • Toronto Star News
      • Toronto Sun
      • National Post
    • Israel Media News
      • Haaretz News
      • The Jerusalem Post
      • The Times of Israel
    • Turkish News Media
      • Anadolu
      • Daily Sabah
      • Hurriyet
      • TRT World
      • Yenisafak
      • NationalTurk
No Result
View All Result
Pakistan News Updates
No Result
View All Result
Home USA News Media New York Times

[New York Times]Indian Court Hands Down Symbolic Sentence for Outspoken Lawyer

August 31, 2020
in New York Times
5 min read
242 11
0
[New York Times]Indian Court Hands Down Symbolic Sentence for Outspoken Lawyer
491
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

RelatedPosts

[New York Times]Opinion | Digital Technology Invaded Our Lives. Now Women May Pay For It.

[New York Times]Opinion | Can You Even Call Deadly Heat ‘Extreme’ Anymore?

[New York Times]Poor Countries Face a Mounting Catastrophe Fueled by Inflation and Debt

[New York Times]Indian Court Hands Down Symbolic Sentence for Outspoken Lawyer


NEW DELHI — India’s Supreme Court on Monday handed down a symbolic sentence — a fine of about 1 cent — to a prominent lawyer who posted tweets critical of the court and its chief justice.

The case against the lawyer, Prashant Bhushan, effectively put India’s highest court on trial, with many lawyers and activists claiming that the conviction alone of Mr. Bhushan was emblematic of the court’s eroding independence and relevance.

Mr. Bhushan faced a maximum sentence of six months in prison for the tweets, which included a photograph of the chief justice astride a Harley-Davidson motorcycle owned by a political ally of the country’s powerful prime minister.

Rights activists feared that a jail term for the outspoken gadfly would quash free speech in the world’s largest democracy and signal a further slip toward authoritarianism.

On Monday, the court told Mr. Bhushan that if he failed to pay the 1 rupee fine he would face three months in jail and lose the right to practice law.

Had the court sentenced Mr. Bhushan to prison, lawyers said it would have been seen as a clear sign of the court’s turn from independent arbiter to political tool.

Lalit Bhasin, the president of the Bar Association of India, an umbrella organization that represents thousands of lawyers, called the fine “unfortunate.”

“You can’t scuttle freedom of expression,” he added.

In June, Mr. Bhushan posted a one-sentence tweet opining about the Indian Supreme Court’s role in eroding freedoms in the country since Prime Minister Narendra Modi took office in 2014. Two days later, he tweeted a photo of the court’s chief justice atop a luxury motorcycle.

Mr. Bhushan had earlier refused to offer the court an apology, saying in a statement that a false expression of regret “would amount to the contempt of my conscience.” At a hearing last week, Mr. Bhushan was repeatedly goaded by the court to issue an apology in an effort to gain the court’s clemency, an action Mr. Bhushan’s lawyers described as an “exercise of coercion.”

Though the two tweets consisted just 478 characters, the court issued a 108-page judgment that found Mr. Bhushan in contempt of court. It said that Mr. Bhushan’s tweets were “scurrilous” and “malicious,” and a “calculated attack on the very foundation of the institution of the judiciary.”

In one of the two tweets he posted, Mr. Bhushan wrote that the court played a role in “how democracy has been destroyed in India” during Mr. Modi’s time in office.

India’s Supreme Court has long been seen as a pillar in the country’s often unruly democracy. It has recently made a series of progressive rulings, including striking down a ban on consensual gay sex and upholding the right to privacy.

Freedom of speech is a fundamental right in India and the court has historically protected contentious speech. In 2015, it repealed a law that stood in the way of freely expressing one’s views on the internet.

But the conviction alone of Mr. Bhushan appeared to reflect a shift in the court’s definition of what amounts to legally protected criticism, experts said.

“Conviction of Prashant Bhushan and sentencing are both unwarranted because he has done nothing which is in contempt of court,” said Colin Gonsalves, a senior lawyer and founder of Human Rights Law Network, a nonprofit that provides pro bono legal services. “Rather his actions have always been his support of independence of the judiciary and against corruption.”

Critics of the court further say that since Mr. Modi’s rise to power, the bench has increasingly become a tool of the prime minister.

In a speech earlier this month, A.P. Shah, a former chief justice of the Delhi High Court, said that the Supreme Court appeared to have “abdicated its role as arbiter,” when it deferred the matter regarding lifting restrictions on the internet and movement in the contested Jammu and Kashmir region, to a government-run committee.

“India is moving toward a form of elected autocracy,” said Mr. Shah.

The court also handed Mr. Modi a series of recent political victories. In November, the court ruled in favor of Hindus in a decades-old dispute over a holy site in Ayodhya contested by Muslims, handing Mr. Modi and his followers a victory in their quest to recast the secular democracy as a Hindu nation.

Mr. Bhushan made a career of taking on the government well before Mr. Modi and his Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party came to power. He filed several corruption complaints under previous governments, including those led by Mr. Modi’s opposition, the Indian National Congress.

But in recent years, he has become one of the Modi administration’s harshest critics. Mr. Bhushan has filed public interest suits accusing Mr. Modi’s government of wrongdoing, and has frequently spoken out about a Supreme Court, which in his estimation, too often sides with the government.

In another tweet, Mr. Bhushan accused Chief Justice Sharad Arvind Bobde of hypocrisy, and posted a photograph of the judge posing on a $67,000 Harley-Davidson motorcycle without a face mask and surrounded by people at a time the country had imposed restrictions to tame the coronavirus pandemic.

Chief Justice Bobde, Mr. Bhushan said, was flouting health rules even though he had placed the court on lockdown “denying citizens their fundamental right to access justice.”

The court said in its judgment that even though physical hearings remain suspended, it has conducted 879 hearings in nearly four months.

The motorcycle was confirmed to belong to the son of a local leader from Mr. Modi’s party in the city of Nagpur.

In convicting Mr. Bhushan earlier this month, the court said in its ruling that his comments were a “calculated attack on the very foundation of the institution of the judiciary.”

In July, Twitter removed both of Mr. Bhushan’s tweets from view in India and activists said the company set a dangerous precedent that could apply to similar future accusations of defamation. In a statement, Twitter said it was committed to protecting free expression in India and around the world.

Jeffrey Gettleman contributed reporting.





Source link

Tags: COURThandslawyerOutspokenSentenceSymbolicTimesIndianYork
Share196Tweet123Send

Related Posts

[New York Times]Opinion | Digital Technology Invaded Our Lives. Now Women May Pay For It.
New York Times

[New York Times]Opinion | Digital Technology Invaded Our Lives. Now Women May Pay For It.

by Latest Headlines
May 19, 2022
[New York Times]Opinion | Can You Even Call Deadly Heat ‘Extreme’ Anymore?
New York Times

[New York Times]Opinion | Can You Even Call Deadly Heat ‘Extreme’ Anymore?

by Latest Headlines
May 18, 2022
[New York Times]Poor Countries Face a Mounting Catastrophe Fueled by Inflation and Debt
New York Times

[New York Times]Poor Countries Face a Mounting Catastrophe Fueled by Inflation and Debt

by Latest Headlines
May 17, 2022
[New York Times]Your Tuesday Briefing: Russia’s Faltering Campaign
New York Times

[New York Times]Your Tuesday Briefing: Russia’s Faltering Campaign

by Latest Headlines
May 17, 2022
[New York Times]Pandit Shiv Kumar Sharma, Master of the Santoor, Dies at 84
New York Times

[New York Times]Pandit Shiv Kumar Sharma, Master of the Santoor, Dies at 84

by Latest Headlines
May 16, 2022
Pakistan News Updates

Our Robo collect all news published about Pakistan and Kashmir in International Media. We are covering more than 80 newspapers & news websites.  

Disclaimer | All logos, Trademark, Newspaper Name, News Agency Name, Brand Name, Websites Name/address, News content/articles, Pictures/photos/images, and videos are copyright, trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders, used in this website is for Information, research and/or reference purpose only. The Source link is provided with every post. The use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.  

  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • USA News
    • Bloomberg
    • Chicago Tribune News
    • CNN News
    • Fox News
    • Huffington Post News
    • Los Angeles Times News
    • ESPN
    • NBC News
    • New York Time News
    • Newsweek News
    • Reddit News
    • Reuters News
    • Time News
    • USA TODAY News
    • Washington Post News
    • Wall Street Journal
  • UK News
    • BBC News
    • Cambridge News UK News
    • Daily Express UK News
    • Daily Mail Online News
    • The Guardian News
    • The Huffington Post UK News
    • The Independent News
    • The Irish Times UK News
    • The Telegraph News
  • Chinese News
    • Beijing Bulletin News
    • China Digital Times News
    • China Military News
    • Chinadaily.com.cn News
    • Ecns News
    • People’s Daily Online News
    • Shanghai Daily News
    • South China Morning Post News
    • SupChina News
    • The China Post News
    • Xinhuanet News
    • Xinwengao News
  • Indian News
    • Business Standard News
    • Daily Excelsior News
    • Deccan Chronicle News
    • Free Press Journal News
    • Hindustantimes News
    • India Today News
    • Kashmir Reader News
    • NDTV News
    • News18 News
    • Northlines News
    • Oneindia News
    • Patrika News
    • Rising Kashmir News
    • Scroll.in News
    • State Times News
    • Telangana Today News
    • The Asian Age News
    • The Financial Express News
    • The Hindu News
    • The Indian Express News
    • The Quint News
    • Times of India News
    • ZeeNews 24 News
  • Arab News
    • Saudigazette
    • Albawaba News
    • Aljazera News
    • Arab News
    • UAE News Media
      • Al Arabiya News
      • Al bayan News
      • Al Ittihad Newspaper News
      • UAE today News
      • The National.ae News
      • Khaleej Times News
      • Emirates 24/7 News
  • Other Media
    • European News Media
      • French News Media
      • German News Media
    • Russian News Media
      • RT News
      • Russia Insider News
      • Sputnik News
      • TASS News
      • The Moscow Times News
    • Canadian News Media
      • CBC News
      • CityNews Toronto News
      • CTV News
      • Financial Post News
      • Global News
      • Reuters News
      • The Globe and Mail News
      • Toronto Star News
      • Toronto Sun
      • National Post
    • Israel Media News
      • Haaretz News
      • The Jerusalem Post
      • The Times of Israel
    • Turkish News Media
      • Anadolu
      • Daily Sabah
      • Hurriyet
      • TRT World
      • Yenisafak
      • NationalTurk

Our Robo collect all news published about Pakistan and Kashmir in International Media. We are covering more than 80 newspapers & news websites.  

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.